Do strategies to increase physical activity among older people work for individuals?

This source preferred by Samuel Nyman and Andrew Callaway

Authors: Nyman, S.R., Goodwin, K., Kwasnicka, D. and Callaway, A.

Start date: 23 April 2015

Journal: Irish Ageing Studies Review

Volume: 6

Issue: 1

Pages: 29

Background Evaluations of techniques to promote physical activity among older people usually adopt a randomised controlled trial (RCT) or similar design. Such designs inform how a technique performs on average for the intervention group but cannot be used for treatment of individuals. N-of-1 RCTs overcome this limitation. We conducted the first N-of-1 RCT of behaviour change techniques with older people to test their effectiveness for increasing walking.

Methods Eight individuals aged 60-87 were randomised to a 2 (goal setting vs. active control) x 2 (self-monitoring vs. active control) factorial N-of-1 RCT over 62 days. Each day, participants were randomised to conditions and walking was objectively measured using pedometers. For goal-setting, participants set themselves a step count goal for that day. For self-monitoring, participants wore a pedometer with the display visible. The time series data was analysed for each individual using linear regression.

Results Overall, compared to controls, both goal-setting and self-monitoring interventions increased daily walking by a median of 922 and 950 steps respectively. However, for individuals the results were mixed. Compared to controls, goal-setting increased walking in 4 out of 8 individuals, with the remaining showing no change or a decrease in walking. Self-monitoring increased walking in 7 out of 8 individuals, with one individual showing a decrease in walking. No linear regression was significant, likely because of insufficient statistical power.

Conclusions N-of-1 trials are useful for testing the effect of physical activity interventions among older people and open new possibilities for the advancement of science and clinical practice.

The data on this page was last updated at 04:42 on September 25, 2017.