Talking a Good Game: Identifying the Discrepancies in Football Coaches' Beliefs and Actions in Player Selection
Authors: Kite, R., Ashford, M., Noon, M., Morris, R. and Clarke, N.
Journal: Journal of Expertise
Volume: 6(4) & 7(1)
Pages: 352-368
eISSN: 2573-2773
ISSN: 2573-2773
Abstract:Coach intuition plays a critical role in the selection of academy players. A coach's beliefs about a player's current abilities and perceived potential are critical in deciding a player's future. Therefore, this study attempted to gain insight towards each coach's experience and beliefs in selecting players, before undertaking a hypothetical selection activity to understand whether coaches act on such knowledge. Twenty-four coaches recruited from 21 unique professional football (soccer) academies (nine Category 1, eight Category 2, and seven Category 3) took part in semi-structured interviews. The findings established that coach beliefs and actions differed, whereby coaches stated a wide range of holistic beliefs towards selection, yet the hypothetical scenario outlined a far narrower selection criteria applied in action. While several beliefs were reinforced, it was also clear that biases were also presented. Maturation-related bias, favoring the more mature players, explained a potential focus on specific physical qualities (speed) and the perceived potential of players. Additionally, a focus on current performance, over wider elements related to perceived future potential, was evident during the selection scenario. Moreover, while subjective input will remain a key contributor to the player selection process, objective assessments and the input of wider multidisciplinary staff should be utilized to help mitigate the above-mentioned issues.
Source: Manual