Why should nurses care if Heidegger was a Nazi? Pragmatics, politics and philosophy in nursing
Authors: Randall, D.C. and Richardson, A.
Journal: Nursing Inquiry
Volume: 28
Issue: 3
eISSN: 1440-1800
ISSN: 1320-7881
DOI: 10.1111/nin.12409
Abstract:Nursing and nurses have become reliant on qualitative methods to understand the meaning of nursing care, and many nurse researchers use Heideggerian Interpretivist phenomenology approaches. Often these nurses are unaware of Martin Heidegger's role in the German National Socialist Party of the 1930s and his allegiance to fascist ideology. We ask: can a bad person have good ideas? In line with pragmatic thinkers such as Richard Rorty, we argue that instead of value judgements on people and their ideas, nurses should consider ideas as a product of a historical/social and political time and space. In urging a critical political engagement, we argue for a Husserlian approach. In opposition to Heidegger's interpretivist phenomenology approach, in which the hegemony of the day is integral to the phenomena being studied, we propose that a more expressive, collaborative engagement using Husserlian descriptive phenomenology approach would serve better in encouraging a more critical engagement with how ideas are used by groups of people, how some groups might be advantaged and others disadvantaged. Our conclusion is that the separation of ideas from political and social context is dangerous, and nurses, including nurse researchers, must understand how their research ideas and methods influence and are influenced by political agendas.
https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/35409/
Source: Scopus
Why should nurses care if Heidegger was a Nazi? Pragmatics, politics and philosophy in nursing.
Authors: Randall, D.C. and Richardson, A.
Journal: Nurs Inq
Volume: 28
Issue: 3
Pages: e12409
eISSN: 1440-1800
DOI: 10.1111/nin.12409
Abstract:Nursing and nurses have become reliant on qualitative methods to understand the meaning of nursing care, and many nurse researchers use Heideggerian Interpretivist phenomenology approaches. Often these nurses are unaware of Martin Heidegger's role in the German National Socialist Party of the 1930s and his allegiance to fascist ideology. We ask: can a bad person have good ideas? In line with pragmatic thinkers such as Richard Rorty, we argue that instead of value judgements on people and their ideas, nurses should consider ideas as a product of a historical/social and political time and space. In urging a critical political engagement, we argue for a Husserlian approach. In opposition to Heidegger's interpretivist phenomenology approach, in which the hegemony of the day is integral to the phenomena being studied, we propose that a more expressive, collaborative engagement using Husserlian descriptive phenomenology approach would serve better in encouraging a more critical engagement with how ideas are used by groups of people, how some groups might be advantaged and others disadvantaged. Our conclusion is that the separation of ideas from political and social context is dangerous, and nurses, including nurse researchers, must understand how their research ideas and methods influence and are influenced by political agendas.
https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/35409/
Source: PubMed
Why should nurses care if Heidegger was a Nazi? Pragmatics, politics and philosophy in nursing
Authors: Randall, D.C. and Richardson, A.
Journal: NURSING INQUIRY
Volume: 28
Issue: 3
eISSN: 1440-1800
ISSN: 1320-7881
DOI: 10.1111/nin.12409
https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/35409/
Source: Web of Science (Lite)
Why should nurses care if Heidegger was a Nazi? Pragmatics, politics and philosophy in Nursing
Authors: Randall, D. and Richardson, A.
Journal: Nurse Inquiry
DOI: 10.1111/nin.12409
Abstract:Nursing and nurses have become reliant on qualitative methods to understand the meaning of nursing care, and many nurse researchers use Heideggerian interpretivist phenomenology approaches. Often these nurses are unaware of Martin Heidegger’s role in the German National Socialist Party of the 1930s and his allegiance to fascist ideology. We ask can a bad person have good ideas? In line with pragmatic thinkers such as Richard Rorty, we argue that instead of value judgements on people and their ideas nurses should considered ideas as a product of a historical/social political time and space. In urging a critical political engagement we argue for a Husserlian approach. In opposition to Heidegger’s interpretivist phenomenology approach, in which the hegemony of the day is integral to the phenomena being studied, we propose that a more expressive collaborative engagement using Husserlian descriptive phenomenology approach would serve better, in encouraging a more critical engagement with how ideas are used by groups of people, how some groups might be advantaged and others disadvantaged. Our conclusion is that the separation of ideas from political social context is dangerous and nurses including nurse researchers must understand how their research ideas and methods influence and are influenced by political agendas.
https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/35409/
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/nin.12409
Source: Manual
Why should nurses care if Heidegger was a Nazi? Pragmatics, politics and philosophy in nursing.
Authors: Randall, D.C. and Richardson, A.
Journal: Nursing inquiry
Volume: 28
Issue: 3
Pages: e12409
eISSN: 1440-1800
ISSN: 1320-7881
DOI: 10.1111/nin.12409
Abstract:Nursing and nurses have become reliant on qualitative methods to understand the meaning of nursing care, and many nurse researchers use Heideggerian Interpretivist phenomenology approaches. Often these nurses are unaware of Martin Heidegger's role in the German National Socialist Party of the 1930s and his allegiance to fascist ideology. We ask: can a bad person have good ideas? In line with pragmatic thinkers such as Richard Rorty, we argue that instead of value judgements on people and their ideas, nurses should consider ideas as a product of a historical/social and political time and space. In urging a critical political engagement, we argue for a Husserlian approach. In opposition to Heidegger's interpretivist phenomenology approach, in which the hegemony of the day is integral to the phenomena being studied, we propose that a more expressive, collaborative engagement using Husserlian descriptive phenomenology approach would serve better in encouraging a more critical engagement with how ideas are used by groups of people, how some groups might be advantaged and others disadvantaged. Our conclusion is that the separation of ideas from political and social context is dangerous, and nurses, including nurse researchers, must understand how their research ideas and methods influence and are influenced by political agendas.
https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/35409/
Source: Europe PubMed Central
Why should nurses care if Heidegger was a Nazi? Pragmatics, politics and philosophy in Nursing
Authors: Randall, D. and Richardson, A.
Journal: Nursing Inquiry
Volume: 28
Issue: 3
ISSN: 1320-7881
Abstract:Nursing and nurses have become reliant on qualitative methods to understand the meaning of nursing care, and many nurse researchers use Heideggerian interpretivist phenomenology approaches. Often these nurses are unaware of Martin Heidegger’s role in the German National Socialist Party of the 1930s and his allegiance to fascist ideology. We ask can a bad person have good ideas? In line with pragmatic thinkers such as Richard Rorty, we argue that instead of value judgements on people and their ideas nurses should considered ideas as a product of a historical/social political time and space. In urging a critical political engagement we argue for a Husserlian approach. In opposition to Heidegger’s interpretivist phenomenology approach, in which the hegemony of the day is integral to the phenomena being studied, we propose that a more expressive collaborative engagement using Husserlian descriptive phenomenology approach would serve better, in encouraging a more critical engagement with how ideas are used by groups of people, how some groups might be advantaged and others disadvantaged. Our conclusion is that the separation of ideas from political social context is dangerous and nurses including nurse researchers must understand how their research ideas and methods influence and are influenced by political agendas.
https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/35409/
Source: BURO EPrints